Apparently mainstream medicine is catching on: if we think we have control over our lives, our health and well-being, it seems to have a beneficial impact on the actual outcome of our health. Imagine that.
Have a look at what this interesting Portuguese study found regarding women and their perceived control of hot flashes.
Perceived control, lifestyle, health, socio-demographic factors and menopause: Impact on hot flashes and night sweats.
Maturitas. 2011 Jun 14;
Authors: Pimenta F, Leal I, Maroco J, Ramos C
OBJECTIVE: To develop a model to predict the perceived severity of hot flashes (HF) and night sweats (NS) in symptomatic middle-aged women. METHODS: This was a cross-sectional study of a community-based sample of 243 women with vasomotor symptoms. Menopausal status was ascertained using the 'Stages of Reproductive Aging Workshop' criteria. Women's 'perceived control' over their symptoms was measured by a validated Portuguese version of the Perceived Control over Hot Flushes Index. Structural equation modelling was employed to construct a causal model of self-reported severity of both HF and NS, using a set of 20 variables: age, marital status, parity, professional status, educational level, family annual income, recent diseases and psychological problems, medical help-seeking behaviour to manage menopausal symptoms, use of hormone therapy and herbal/soy products, menopause status, intake of alcohol, coffee and hot beverages, smoking, physical exercise, body mass index and perceived control. RESULTS: Significant predictors of perceived severity were the use of hormone therapy for both HF (β=-.245; p=.022) and NS (β=-.298; p=.008), coffee intake for both HF (β=-.234; p=.039) and NS (β=-.258; p=.029) and perceived control for both HF (β=-1.0; p<.001) and NS (β=-1.0; p<.001). The variables explained respectively 67% and 72% of the variability in the perceived severity of HF and NS. Women with high perceived control had a significantly lower frequency (t(235)=2.022; p=.044) and intensity of HF (t(217)=3.582; p<.001); similarly, participants with high perceived control presented a lower frequency (t(235)=3.267; p<.001) and intensity (t(210)=3.376; p<.001) of NS. CONCLUSION: Perceived control was the strongest predictor of the self-reported severity of both HF and NS. Other causal predictors were hormone therapy and caffeine intake. All three were associated with less severe vasomotor symptoms.
PMID: 21680119 [PubMed - as supplied by publisher]
About Me
- Brooke Halgren
- I am a 2012 Naturopathic Doctoral Candidate at National College of Natural Medicine in Portland, OR. I am excited to share and exchange knowledge about health and wellness on my journey to becoming a Naturopathic Doctor.
Monday, June 20, 2011
Wednesday, June 15, 2011
Deoderant may not be coming up not smelling like roses afterall....
Deodorants are the leading cause of allergic contact dermatitis to fragrance ingredients.
Contact Dermatitis. 2011; 64(5):258-64 (ISSN: 1600-0536)
Heisterberg MV ; Menné T ; Andersen KE ; Avnstorp C ; Kristensen B ; Kristensen O ; Kaaber K ; Laurberg G ; Henrik Nielsen N ; Sommerlund M ; Thormann J ; Veien NK ; Vissing S ; Johansen JD
Department of Dermato-allergology, National Allergy Research Centre, Gentofte Hospital, University of Copenhagen, 2900 Hellerup, Denmark. mavohe01@geh.regionh.dk
BACKGROUND: Fragrances frequently cause contact allergy, and cosmetic products are the main causes of fragrance contact allergy. As the various products have distinctive forms of application and composition of ingredients, some product groups are potentially more likely to play a part in allergic reactions than others.
AIM: To determine which cosmetic product groups cause fragrance allergy among Danish eczema patients.
METHOD: This was a retrospective study based on data collected by members of the Danish Contact Dermatitis Group. Participants (N = 17,716) were consecutively patch tested with fragrance markers from the European baseline series (2005-2009).
RESULTS: Of the participants, 10.1% had fragrance allergy, of which 42.1% was caused by a cosmetic product: deodorants accounted for 25%, and scented lotions 24.4%. A sex difference was apparent, as deodorants were significantly more likely to be listed as the cause of fragrance allergy in men (odds ratio 2.2) than in women. Correlation was observed between deodorants listed as the cause of allergy and allergy detected with fragrance mix II (FM II) and hydroxyisohexyl 3-cyclohexene carboxaldehyde.
CONCLUSION: Deodorants were the leading causes of fragrance allergy, especially among men. Seemingly, deodorants have an 'unhealthy' composition of the fragrance chemicals present in FM II.
PreMedline Identifier:21480912
Contact Dermatitis. 2011; 64(5):258-64 (ISSN: 1600-0536)
Heisterberg MV ; Menné T ; Andersen KE ; Avnstorp C ; Kristensen B ; Kristensen O ; Kaaber K ; Laurberg G ; Henrik Nielsen N ; Sommerlund M ; Thormann J ; Veien NK ; Vissing S ; Johansen JD
Department of Dermato-allergology, National Allergy Research Centre, Gentofte Hospital, University of Copenhagen, 2900 Hellerup, Denmark. mavohe01@geh.regionh.dk
BACKGROUND: Fragrances frequently cause contact allergy, and cosmetic products are the main causes of fragrance contact allergy. As the various products have distinctive forms of application and composition of ingredients, some product groups are potentially more likely to play a part in allergic reactions than others.
AIM: To determine which cosmetic product groups cause fragrance allergy among Danish eczema patients.
METHOD: This was a retrospective study based on data collected by members of the Danish Contact Dermatitis Group. Participants (N = 17,716) were consecutively patch tested with fragrance markers from the European baseline series (2005-2009).
RESULTS: Of the participants, 10.1% had fragrance allergy, of which 42.1% was caused by a cosmetic product: deodorants accounted for 25%, and scented lotions 24.4%. A sex difference was apparent, as deodorants were significantly more likely to be listed as the cause of fragrance allergy in men (odds ratio 2.2) than in women. Correlation was observed between deodorants listed as the cause of allergy and allergy detected with fragrance mix II (FM II) and hydroxyisohexyl 3-cyclohexene carboxaldehyde.
CONCLUSION: Deodorants were the leading causes of fragrance allergy, especially among men. Seemingly, deodorants have an 'unhealthy' composition of the fragrance chemicals present in FM II.
PreMedline Identifier:21480912
Tuesday, June 14, 2011
Q: I’ve heard a lot about fish oil? Is it something I should take?
A: Fish oils contain omega-3 essential fatty acids which help to reduce blood viscosity, increase good cholesterol (HDL) and lower triglycerides. Essential fatty acids cannot be made by the human body but are ‘essential’ for normal metabolism. Therefore, we must acquire them in our diet. Omega-3 fatty acids are often lacking in the modern diet, which is instead higher in omega-6 type fatty acids. Omega-6 fatty acids are found mostly in animal products and contribute to the body’s inflammatory response, vital for our immune system. The problem is not the omega-6 fatty acids, but rather that our diet provides us with too much omega-6 and not enough omega-3. The idea behind supplementing with fish oil is to provide the body with a healthy amount of omega-3 oils, and to create a more appropriate balance between omega 6 and 3 fatty acids in the body. Because fish oils are so beneficial in this aspect, they are an appropriate supplement for many people.
If you are vegetarian, vegan or opposed to animal supplements, you can also consider other oils that contain healthy amounts of omega 3 oils. Fish oils are often the first choice because they provide the greatest amount of omega 3 oils per serving. There are, however, many other non-animal sources of omega 3 fatty acids including flax seeds, hemp, canola, walnut, pumpkins, soy, algae, and purslane.
Talk to your Naturopathic Physician about whether a fish oil supplement is a good choice for you and what to look for in selecting a supplement. It is important to read all labels and look for certified products tested for Mercury and other contaminants and is guaranteed to be shelf-stable (to not turn rancid).
References
Marz, Russell B. Medical Nutrition from Marz. 2nd ed. Portland: Omni-Press, 1999.
Thom, Dick. Notes from “Clinical and Physical Diagnosis.” National College of Natural Medicine. 2009-2010.
Thursday, June 9, 2011
Dr. Mercola's Tips for Keeping Joints and Muscles Healthy
What strategies can you use to help keep your joints healthy and flexible?
But first, allow me to discuss the joint support supplement everyone talks about – which many believe is not effective.
Yet, many are unhappy with it, or experience health problems from it.
Why? Learn more at http://products.mercola.com/joint-support/?source=nl
- Exercise. There's a common urban legend that exercise is bad for your joints.
Most people have little appreciation for how powerful exercise can be in supporting joint function. Vigorous low-impact exercise is beneficial for your joints, as well as for cardiovascular, pulmonary, and other systems in your body.
It's simply a myth that you can 'wear down' your knees just from average levels of exercise and/or normal activity. In fact, inactivity causes your muscles to become weaker and actually works against optimal joint flexibility and comfort.
One caution, however when using this valuable tool, you need to start slowly if you have not been exercising regularly, and build up to higher activity levels otherwise you risk incurring an injury that could cause really set you back..
If typical vigorous exercise is not easy for you, try walking, tai chi and yoga as they are very low impact, yet offer many health benefits.
- Achieve your optimal weight to improve your bio-mechanic function. One of the outstanding benefits of exercise is its ability to help you achieve and maintain your ideal weight which is highly beneficial to your joints.
Overweight and obese people compromise joint comfort more than those who are carrying their ideal load. Each additional kilogram (2.2 pounds) of body mass increases the compressive load over your knee by roughly 4 kilograms (nearly 9 pounds).
Research shows that a weight loss of as little as 11 pounds can have a positive effect on joint function. And those who are at their optimal weight experience increased joint health as compared to those who are obese or overweight.
So you go full circle losing weight reduces the load on your joints and makes it easier to exercise, and exercising helps you lose weight and supports your joint health.
- Eat a higher quality diet. Eliminate sugar and starchy carbs from your diet. And definitely stop drinking soda. These foods do absolutely nothing to support healthy joints or a healthy body. In fact, their potential for damage is well documented.
I believe you should limit your total fructose from ALL sources to no more than 25 grams per day, as it raises uric acid levels, which is hard on your joints. Now, chances are, you consume substantially more than 25 grams per day. Approximately of Americans consume a whopping 134 grams of fructose every day!
Within your 25 grams of fructose, you could consider including some tart cherries or concentrated tart cherry juice. They contain anthocyanins and bioflavonoids, which help support a healthy immune response for your joints and whole body health.
Also, in my opinion, you should base your food choices on your nutritional type to ensure you optimize your ideal macronutrient ratios.
- Optimize your vitamin D levels. Vitamin D also supports a healthy immune response. Please recognize that during the fall, winter and early spring in most of the U.S., Canada, and Europe, your vitamin D levels can drop precipitously. If your levels fall, you give up the support this vitamin offers for your joints and your whole body.
- Get plenty of omega-3 fatty acids from krill or high quality fish oil. Omega-3's support your joint health.
- Try EFT Emotional Freedom Technique. EFT is an energy psychology tool that uses tapping and acupuncture meridians to help resolve the emotional factors that contribute to less-than-optimal health.
But first, allow me to discuss the joint support supplement everyone talks about – which many believe is not effective.
What You Should Know About Glucosamine and Chondroitin
For the past decade, people have been rushing on board the glucosamine and chondroitin train for joint care.Yet, many are unhappy with it, or experience health problems from it.
Why? Learn more at http://products.mercola.com/joint-support/?source=nl
Wednesday, May 11, 2011
Cardiovascular Benefits of Vitamin D
| 1. | J Clin Lipidol. 2010 Mar-Apr;4(2):113-9. Epub 2010 Feb 6.Vitamin D is associated with atheroprotective high-density lipoprotein profile in postmenopausal women.Kazlauskaite R, Powell LH, Mandapakala C, Cursio JF, Avery EF, Calvin J.SourceDepartment of Preventive Medicine, Rush University Medical Center, 1700 W. Van Buren St, Ste 470, Chicago, IL 60612, USA. rasa_kazlauskaite@rush.eduAbstractBACKGROUND:Low vitamin D has been associated with low levels of high-density lipoprotein (HDL) cholesterol, a marker of coronary risk. Whether atheroprotective HDL particle composition accounts for this association and whether fat affects this association is not known.OBJECTIVE:To explore the association between HDL particle composition and 25-hydroxy vitamin D (25[OH]D) in post-menopausal women.METHODS:Vitamin D levels and lipoprotein composition were assessed in fasting blood samples of apparently healthy women from a diverse Chicago community. Visceral (VAT) and subcutaneous (SAT) abdominal fat area were assessed using computed tomography. Total body fat mass was measured by dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry.RESULTS:We enrolled 78 women (50% black; 50% white), age 48 to 64 years, all of whom were participants in a longitudinal study of fat patterning. They had a mean 25[OH]D of 31 ± 15 μg/L, HDL cholesterol 57±11 mg/dL, and large HDL particle subclass 8.6±3.4 μmol/L. In a multivariable-adjusted regression model, each 5 μg/L higher 25[OH]D predicted 0.57 μmol/L (95%CI 0.20-0.95) higher large HDL particles, independent of race, season, and total HDL particle concentration. This association was only partially confounded by total body fat mass (0.49, 95%CI 0.10-0.89), SAT (0.50, 95%CI 0.11-0.90), or VAT (0.37, 95%CI 0.01-0.74). Age did not significantly influence the strength of associations.CONCLUSIONS:Higher 25[OH]D levels are associated with large HDL particles. This association is stronger than that of HDL cholesterol and only partially confounded by body fat. Theoretically, vitamin D may protect against cardiovascular risk by promoting formation of large HDL particles, affecting reverse cholesterol transport.Copyright © 2010 National Lipid Association. Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. |
Monday, May 9, 2011
Low-Salt Diet Ineffective, Study Finds. Disagreement Abounds.
Many studies have shown the benefits of a salt-restricted diet in treatment of hypertension. The study mentioned in this article examined patients who did not have a pre-existing diagnosis of hypertension. Though it has its flaws, it is certainly interesting to read up on what the investigators found in terms of salt restriction and hypertension. Happy reading!
Brooke H
This copy is for your personal, noncommercial use only. You can order presentation-ready copies for distribution to your colleagues, clients or customers here or use the "Reprints" tool that appears next to any article. Visit www.nytreprints.com for samples and additional information. Order a reprint of this article now.
Brooke H
This copy is for your personal, noncommercial use only. You can order presentation-ready copies for distribution to your colleagues, clients or customers here or use the "Reprints" tool that appears next to any article. Visit www.nytreprints.com for samples and additional information. Order a reprint of this article now.
May 3, 2011
By GINA KOLATA
A new study found that low-salt diets increase the risk of death from heart attacks and strokes and do not prevent high blood pressure, but the research’s limitations mean the debate over the effects of salt in the diet is far from over.
In fact, officials at the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention felt so strongly that the study was flawed that they criticized it in an interview, something they normally do not do.
Dr. Peter Briss, a medical director at the centers, said that the study was small; that its subjects were relatively young, with an average age of 40 at the start; and that with few cardiovascular events, it was hard to draw conclusions. And the study, Dr. Briss and others say, flies in the face of a body of evidence indicating that higher sodium consumption can increase the risk of cardiovascular disease.
“At the moment, this study might need to be taken with a grain of salt,” he said.
The study is published in the May 4 issue of The Journal of the American Medical Association. It involved only those without high blood pressure at the start, was observational, considered at best suggestive and not conclusive. It included 3,681 middle-aged Europeans who did not have high blood pressure or cardiovascular disease and followed them for an average of 7.9 years.
The researchers assessed the participants’ sodium consumption at the study’s start and at its conclusion by measuring the amount of sodium excreted in urine over a 24-hour period. All the sodium that is consumed is excreted in urine within a day, so this method is the most precise way to determine sodium consumption.
The investigators found that the less salt people ate, the more likely they were to die of heart disease — 50 people in the lowest third of salt consumption (2.5 grams of sodium per day) died during the study as compared with 24 in the medium group (3.9 grams of sodium per day) and 10 in the highest salt consumption group (6.0 grams of sodium per day). And while those eating the most salt had, on average, a slight increase in systolic blood pressure — a 1.71-millimeter increase in pressure for each 2.5-gram increase in sodium per day — they were no more likely to develop hypertension.
“If the goal is to prevent hypertension” with lower sodium consumption, said the lead author, Dr. Jan A. Staessen, a professor of medicine at the University of Leuven, in Belgium, “this study shows it does not work.”
But among the study’s other problems, Dr. Briss said, its subjects who seemed to consume the smallest amount of sodium also provided less urine than those consuming more, an indication that they might not have collected all of their urine in an 24-hour period.
Dr. Frank Sacks of the Harvard School of Public Health agreed and also said the study was flawed.
“It’s a problematic study,” Dr. Sacks said. “We shouldn’t be guiding any kind of public health decisions on it.”
Dr. Michael Alderman, a blood pressure researcher at Albert Einstein College of Medicine and editor of the American Journal of Hypertension, said medical literature on salt and health effects was inconsistent. But, Dr. Alderman said, the new study is not the only one to find adverse effects of low-sodium diets. His own study, with people who had high blood pressure, found that those who ate the least salt were most likely to die.
Dr. Alderman said that he once was an unpaid consultant for the Salt Institute but that he now did no consulting for it or for the food industry and did not receive any support or take any money from industry groups.
Lowering salt consumption, Dr. Alderman said, has consequences beyond blood pressure. It also, for example, increases insulin resistance, which can increase the risk of heart disease.
“Diet is a complicated business,” he said. “There are going to be unintended consequences.”
One problem with the salt debates, Dr. Alderman said, is that all the studies are inadequate. Either they are short-term intervention studies in which people are given huge amounts of salt and then deprived of salt to see effects on blood pressure or they are studies, like this one, that observe populations and ask if those who happen to consume less salt are healthier.
“Observational studies tell you what people will experience if they select a diet,” Dr. Alderman said. “They do not tell you what will happen if you change peoples’ sodium intake.”
What is needed, Dr. Alderman said, is a large study in which people are randomly assigned to follow a low-sodium diet or not and followed for years to see if eating less salt improves health and reduces the death rate from cardiovascular disease.
But that study, others say, will never happen.
“This is one of those really interesting situations,” said Dr. Lawrence Appel, a professor of medicine, epidemiology and international health at Johns Hopkins Medical Institutions. “You can say, ‘O.K., let’s dismiss the observational studies because they have all these problems.’ ” But, he said, despite the virtues of a randomized controlled clinical trial, such a study “will never ever be done.” It would be impossible to keep people on a low-sodium diet for years with so much sodium added to prepared foods.
Dr. Briss adds that it would not be prudent to defer public health actions while researchers wait for results of a clinical trial that might not even be feasible.
Dr. Alderman disagrees.
“The low-salt advocates suggest that all 300 million Americans be subjected to a low-salt diet. But if they can’t get people on a low-salt diet for a clinical trial, what are they talking about?”
He added: “It will cost money, but that’s why we do science. It will also cost money to change the composition of food.”
Saturday, May 7, 2011
So You Want to Be a Doctor?
May 5, 2011, 12:01 am
original link: http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/05/05/a-better-medical-school-admissions-test/?ref=health
I was impressed.
But her enthusiasm dipped sharply when she told me she was preparing for the MCATs, the Medical College Admission Test, the required standardized test that measures mastery of the pre-medical curriculum. She was putting all her extracurricular work on hold so she could focus on reviewing biology, physics, chemistry and organic chemistry for the exam. “Does my ability to memorize the Krebs cycle and Bernoulli’s equation really have anything to do with what kind of doctor I’ll be?” she asked.
The answer, it turns out, is yes — and no.
The first MCAT, then referred to as the Scholastic Aptitude Test for Medical Schools, was administered in 1928 and represented an effort to address the significant medical school dropout rates of the time. Up until that point, medical school applicants had been evaluated, and accepted, on the basis of stray bits of biographical information, random letters of endorsement, a few prior grades or the existence of a high school diploma. As many as half of those accepted eventually quit, resulting in huge losses of time, energy, educational resources and money. But thanks in part to the MCAT, by the mid-1940s the medical school attrition rate had plummeted to less than 10 percent, even as the standardized exam was becoming a much-maligned rite of passage for aspiring young doctors.
Over the years, the MCAT has gone through four major revisions and has only strengthened its ability to predict success in medical school, particularly when evaluated in combination with grades. Each year more than 70,000 students take the exam, vying for a little more than 19,500 medical school slots. These days, fewer than 4 percent of those finally accepted drop out.
But the MCAT has had one major failing in its otherwise brilliant performance: It has been unable to consistently predict personal and professional characteristics. As early as 1946, medical educators were trying to design the MCAT in a way that might tease out such information, but they, and those who followed, were unable to succeed.
Now the MCAT is about to undergo its fifth revision, the first in nearly 25 years. Last month, the Association of American Medical Colleges, the national organization that administers the MCAT, released the preliminary recommendations of a 22-member advisory committee that has been studying the issue for the last three years. They recommend, among other things, lengthening the four-and-a-half hour exam by 90 minutes and adding questions on disciplines like sociology and psychology. The new exam would also test analytical and reasoning skills in areas like ethics, philosophy and cross-cultural studies, which could include questions about how someone living in a particular demographic situation, for example, might perceive and interact with others.
Despite what some view as a long overdue re-examination of this linchpin of medical school admissions, many medical educators, including members of the advisory committee, remain cautious about tampering with a test that has proved successful so far.
“It’s like trying to improve a Honda,” said Dr. Ronald D. Franks, vice chairman of the committee and vice president of health sciences at the University of South Alabama College of Medicine in Mobile. “When you’ve got something that’s working extremely well, you can make improvements, but you’ve got to be mindful of the services it has rendered.”
Those services can be gargantuan. Jefferson Medical College in Philadelphia, for example, receives almost 10,000 applications each year and must whittle those numbers down to 800 for interviews for the 260 available slots in each class. In combination with grades, the MCAT can help admissions officers eliminate a quarter of the applications.
“But we and other medical schools have so many great applications from the standpoint of just numbers that we usually also need to go through other parts of the application as well,” said Dr. Clara A. Callahan, dean of student affairs and admissions at Jefferson and the lead author of one of the largest longitudinal studies on the predictive validity of the MCAT. “You want to make sure someone isn’t just saying that he or she wants to help people.”
It’s likely that Dr. Callahan and other medical school admissions officers will have to continue to look beyond the MCAT to learn more about their applicants’ personal qualities. The science of personality testing has advanced tremendously over the last 25 years, but the committee felt it was still unclear how accurately a test could predict traits like integrity, altruism and the ability to collaborate. Some members were uncomfortable, too, with the long-term implications. “Will we end up labeling someone forever with a 9.2 for their personality?” Dr. Franks asked.
Only time will tell whether this newest version succeeds where earlier ones have not. But one thing is certain: Taking the MCAT is likely to remain a rite of passage for doctors-to-be for years to come.
“The reality is that we doctors are taking standardized tests – in-service exams, board exams, recertification exams – all our life,” Dr. Callahan said. “It’s something people have to master in medical school and beyond, so it’s nice to be able to accurately predict at the outset how someone will do with them in medical school and beyond.”
The MCAT advisory committee is continuing to solicit opinions through its Web site until February. The new exam will be administered beginning in 2015.
A Better Medical School Admissions Test
By PAULINE W. CHEN, M.D.Jesus Jauregui/Getty Images
Recently the college-age daughter of a friend talked to me about her dream of becoming a doctor. She was doing well as a psychology major and in her pre-medical courses, was working as a research assistant for a pediatrician at a nearby medical school and volunteered on the cancer ward at a children’s hospital.I was impressed.
But her enthusiasm dipped sharply when she told me she was preparing for the MCATs, the Medical College Admission Test, the required standardized test that measures mastery of the pre-medical curriculum. She was putting all her extracurricular work on hold so she could focus on reviewing biology, physics, chemistry and organic chemistry for the exam. “Does my ability to memorize the Krebs cycle and Bernoulli’s equation really have anything to do with what kind of doctor I’ll be?” she asked.
The answer, it turns out, is yes — and no.
The first MCAT, then referred to as the Scholastic Aptitude Test for Medical Schools, was administered in 1928 and represented an effort to address the significant medical school dropout rates of the time. Up until that point, medical school applicants had been evaluated, and accepted, on the basis of stray bits of biographical information, random letters of endorsement, a few prior grades or the existence of a high school diploma. As many as half of those accepted eventually quit, resulting in huge losses of time, energy, educational resources and money. But thanks in part to the MCAT, by the mid-1940s the medical school attrition rate had plummeted to less than 10 percent, even as the standardized exam was becoming a much-maligned rite of passage for aspiring young doctors.
Over the years, the MCAT has gone through four major revisions and has only strengthened its ability to predict success in medical school, particularly when evaluated in combination with grades. Each year more than 70,000 students take the exam, vying for a little more than 19,500 medical school slots. These days, fewer than 4 percent of those finally accepted drop out.
But the MCAT has had one major failing in its otherwise brilliant performance: It has been unable to consistently predict personal and professional characteristics. As early as 1946, medical educators were trying to design the MCAT in a way that might tease out such information, but they, and those who followed, were unable to succeed.
Now the MCAT is about to undergo its fifth revision, the first in nearly 25 years. Last month, the Association of American Medical Colleges, the national organization that administers the MCAT, released the preliminary recommendations of a 22-member advisory committee that has been studying the issue for the last three years. They recommend, among other things, lengthening the four-and-a-half hour exam by 90 minutes and adding questions on disciplines like sociology and psychology. The new exam would also test analytical and reasoning skills in areas like ethics, philosophy and cross-cultural studies, which could include questions about how someone living in a particular demographic situation, for example, might perceive and interact with others.
Despite what some view as a long overdue re-examination of this linchpin of medical school admissions, many medical educators, including members of the advisory committee, remain cautious about tampering with a test that has proved successful so far.
“It’s like trying to improve a Honda,” said Dr. Ronald D. Franks, vice chairman of the committee and vice president of health sciences at the University of South Alabama College of Medicine in Mobile. “When you’ve got something that’s working extremely well, you can make improvements, but you’ve got to be mindful of the services it has rendered.”
Those services can be gargantuan. Jefferson Medical College in Philadelphia, for example, receives almost 10,000 applications each year and must whittle those numbers down to 800 for interviews for the 260 available slots in each class. In combination with grades, the MCAT can help admissions officers eliminate a quarter of the applications.
“But we and other medical schools have so many great applications from the standpoint of just numbers that we usually also need to go through other parts of the application as well,” said Dr. Clara A. Callahan, dean of student affairs and admissions at Jefferson and the lead author of one of the largest longitudinal studies on the predictive validity of the MCAT. “You want to make sure someone isn’t just saying that he or she wants to help people.”
It’s likely that Dr. Callahan and other medical school admissions officers will have to continue to look beyond the MCAT to learn more about their applicants’ personal qualities. The science of personality testing has advanced tremendously over the last 25 years, but the committee felt it was still unclear how accurately a test could predict traits like integrity, altruism and the ability to collaborate. Some members were uncomfortable, too, with the long-term implications. “Will we end up labeling someone forever with a 9.2 for their personality?” Dr. Franks asked.
Only time will tell whether this newest version succeeds where earlier ones have not. But one thing is certain: Taking the MCAT is likely to remain a rite of passage for doctors-to-be for years to come.
“The reality is that we doctors are taking standardized tests – in-service exams, board exams, recertification exams – all our life,” Dr. Callahan said. “It’s something people have to master in medical school and beyond, so it’s nice to be able to accurately predict at the outset how someone will do with them in medical school and beyond.”
The MCAT advisory committee is continuing to solicit opinions through its Web site until February. The new exam will be administered beginning in 2015.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)